When it comes to moving, one of the biggest decisions you’ll face is choosing the right rental truck service. With several options available, such as U-Haul, Penske, and Budget, selecting the right one for your needs can be overwhelming. In this article, we’ll compare these three popular rental truck companies, examining their pricing, vehicle options, customer service, and overall user experience to help you make an informed decision.

On This Page

Rental Trucks: A Comprehensive Comparison

Rental Trucks: A Comprehensive Comparison

Whether you’re moving across town or across the country, one of the most significant decisions you’ll make is which rental truck service to use. Three of the most recognized names in the business are U-Haul, Penske, and Budget. Each company offers a variety of options and features that cater to different needs, budgets, and moving experiences.

Overview of the Companies

U-Haul

Founded in 1945, U-Haul is one of the oldest and most recognized names in the moving industry. They provide a wide range of rental trucks, trailers, and moving supplies. U-Haul’s extensive network of locations across the U.S. and Canada makes it easily accessible for most customers.

Penske

Penske Truck Leasing is another strong contender in the rental truck market, offering services since the 1960s. Known for its high-quality vehicles and excellent customer service, Penske primarily focuses on commercial and long-distance moves. Their fleet is modern and well-maintained, providing customers with a reliable moving experience.

Budget

Budget Truck Rental is part of the Budget Group, which has been in business since 1958. Budget is known for its competitive pricing and variety of truck sizes. Their services cater to both residential and commercial customers, making them a versatile choice for many.

Pricing

U-Haul:

U-Haul’s pricing model can be somewhat complex, with costs varying based on factors such as location, truck size, rental duration, and time of year. While U-Haul frequently advertises low base rates, additional fees for mileage, fuel, insurance, and equipment rentals can quickly add up. However, many customers appreciate the availability of one-way rentals, which can be convenient for long-distance moves.U-Haul is also known for its competitive pricing, which often appears enticing at first glance. The base rates for local moves can be low, but additional fees can add up quickly. U-Haul’s pricing structure typically includes:

Mileage fees, which are charged per mile driven
Fuel costs, as customers must return the truck with the same amount of fuel
Insurance and damage waivers, which can significantly increase the total cost

For long-distance moves, U-Haul’s pricing can vary widely based on the demand, distance, and time of year. It is essential to read the fine print and consider all potential costs before booking.

Penske:

Penske typically offers a straightforward pricing structure that includes mileage and fuel costs. Their rates may be slightly higher than U-Haul’s, but they often include features such as unlimited mileage on one-way rentals, which can save money for long-distance trips. Additionally, Penske frequently runs promotions that can help customers secure lower rates, especially during off-peak moving seasons. Penske generally offers transparent pricing, particularly for long-distance moves. Their rates include:

Unlimited mileage on one-way rentals, which is a significant advantage for long-distance movers
Free unlimited mileage on local moves
A flat fee for rental, which often includes additional features like roadside assistance

While Penske’s pricing might be higher than U-Haul’s for local moves, the absence of mileage fees for long trips often balances out the costs, making it a cost-effective option for many.

Budget:

Budget Truck Rental is known for its competitive pricing, often positioning itself as the most affordable option among the three companies. Like U-Haul, Budget also employs a pricing structure that considers mileage, rental duration, and additional equipment. Customers can benefit from various discounts, especially for AAA members, students, and military personnel. Budget’s pricing is competitive, especially for local moves. They offer:

A wide range of discounts, including those for military personnel, AAA members, and senior citizens
A lower base rate, which is particularly appealing for budget-conscious renters
Additional fees for mileage and fuel that can add up similarly to U-Haul’s pricing structure

Budget’s long-distance rates tend to be on par with Penske, providing similar value in terms of included features.

Truck Options

U-Haul:

U-Haul boasts a large fleet with a variety of truck sizes, from 10-foot trucks ideal for small apartments to 26-foot trucks suitable for larger homes. They also offer cargo vans and pickup trucks for smaller loads. U-Haul’s trucks are generally well-maintained, but customers have reported variability in condition depending on the location. U-Haul truck come with handy features such as:

Low deck heights to make loading the moving truck easier
Granny space above the cab for extra cargo space

Penske:

Penske’s fleet consists of newer, well-maintained trucks, typically under two years old. They offer a range of sizes, including 12-foot, 16-foot, and 22-foot options, catering primarily to local and long-distance moves. Penske trucks are equipped with features such as:

A flat load floor, making loading and unloading easier
A larger cab area for added comfort during long trips

The uniformity and maintenance of Penske’s fleet often give customers peace of mind regarding reliability and safety.

Budget:

Budget provides a range of trucks similar to U-Haul, offering options from 12-foot trucks to larger 26-foot models. However, their fleet may not be as extensive or as new as Penske’s. Budget trucks also come with essential features like air conditioning and automatic transmissions, making them accessible to a broader audience. However, customers have occasionally noted that truck availability can be inconsistent. At Budget they provide features such as:

Various options for moving supplies and additional equipment
Competitively low rates

Customer Service

U-Haul:

Customer service experiences with U-Haul can be mixed. While some customers report satisfactory interactions, others highlight issues with availability, long wait times at locations, and difficulties in reaching customer support. The decentralized nature of U-Haul’s locations means experiences can vary significantly based on the specific rental location.

Penske:

Penske is generally praised for its customer service. They offer 24/7 roadside assistance, which can be a significant advantage during a long move. Many customers report positive experiences with staff, noting their willingness to help and provide information. Penske’s centralized approach to customer service means that issues are often resolved more efficiently.

Budget:

Budget’s customer service experience is also mixed. While some customers have reported excellent service at local rental locations, others have noted difficulties in reaching support and dealing with issues related to reservations and availability. They have been working to improve customer service through various initiatives, but it remains a mixed bag.

Additional Features

U-Haul:

U-Haul provides various additional features, including:

Moving supplies, such as boxes, tape, and packing materials, available for purchase at their locations
A towing option for cars or trailers
Online reservation and management tools for added convenience

Penske:

Penske stands out with several additional benefits:

Free unlimited mileage on one-way rentals, which is a significant selling point
Discounts for AAA members and military personnel
A complimentary moving truck guide, which helps customers plan their move

Budget:

The Budget truck rental company also offers useful additional features, including:

A comprehensive selection of moving supplies for purchase
Competitive discounts for various groups
An online booking system that is user-friendly and straightforward

Final Thoughts

Choosing the right rental truck service for your move involves weighing several factors, including pricing, truck options, customer service, and additional features.

U-Haul is a solid choice for those looking for low base rates and a wide variety of truck sizes, particularly for local moves, but be wary of additional fees.

Penske offers excellent customer service, newer trucks, and unlimited mileage for long-distance moves, making it a great option for those prioritizing reliability and peace of mind.

Budget stands out for its competitive pricing and extensive discount options, ideal for budget-conscious movers, though its fleet may not be as extensive or well-maintained as Penske’s.

Ultimately, the best choice will depend on your specific needs, budget, and preferences. Taking the time to research and compare your options can help ensure a smoother and more cost-effective moving experience.

FAQs

What are the main differences between U-Haul, Penske, and Budget?

U-Haul offers a wide range of truck sizes, along with additional services like trailer rentals and self-storage options. It is well-known for its extensive network and convenience.
Penske tends to focus on providing newer trucks with better mileage and reliability. It offers unlimited mileage on one-way rentals, which can be beneficial for long-distance moves.
Budget often provides competitive pricing and promotions, particularly for local moves. It typically offers a variety of truck sizes as well but might have fewer locations than U-Haul.

Which company offers the best rates for local moves?

Budget often has the most competitive rates for local moves, especially with promotions. However, rates can vary based on demand and location, so it’s a good idea to compare prices from all three companies.

Are there mileage restrictions with these rental trucks?

U-Haul generally has mileage charges for local moves, but their one-way rentals usually come with a set number of miles included.
Penske provides unlimited mileage on one-way rentals, which can be a significant advantage for long-distance moves.
Budget typically charges for mileage on local rentals but may offer unlimited mileage on certain one-way moves.

What are the age requirements for renting a truck?

Most companies, including U-Haul, Penske, and Budget, require drivers to be at least 18 years old to rent a truck. However, some locations may have a minimum age of 21 or even 25, especially for larger vehicles. Additional fees may apply for younger drivers.

How do the truck sizes compare between U-Haul, Penske, and Budget?

All three companies offer a variety of truck sizes, typically ranging from 10-foot to 26-foot trucks. However, the exact sizes and availability can vary by location. U-Haul is known for its extensive range, while Penske often emphasizes larger trucks for commercial use. See Moving Truck Rental for more information about truck sizes.

Which company has better customer service?

Customer service experiences can vary by location and individual circumstances. Generally, Penske is often praised for its customer service and the quality of its trucks. U-Haul, while widely available, has mixed reviews regarding service quality. Budget can also have varied reviews depending on the location.

Do these companies offer insurance or protection plans?

Yes, all three companies offer optional insurance and protection plans to cover damages and liabilities during the rental period. It’s advisable to review each company’s coverage options and terms to select the best fit for your needs. Visit Rental Truck Insurance for more information about rent a truck insurance coverages.

Can I return the truck after hours?

Yes, all three companies typically offer after-hours drop-off options. However, the process may differ, so it’s best to check specific instructions provided during the rental process.

Which company is best for long-distance moves?

Penske is often recommended for long-distance moves due to its unlimited mileage policy and reputation for reliability. However, U-Haul also offers competitive one-way rental options, and Budget can be cost-effective, so it’s worth comparing all three based on your specific route and needs.